Overcoming the pitfalls in employee performance evaluation: an application of ratings mode of the analytic hierarchy process

Islam, Rafikul and Periaiah, Nagendran (2023) Overcoming the pitfalls in employee performance evaluation: an application of ratings mode of the analytic hierarchy process. Journal of Entrepreneurship, Management and Innovation, 19 (2). pp. 127-157. ISSN 2299-7075 E-ISSN 2299-7326

Preview	PDF (Article) - Published Version Download (1MB) | Preview
Preview	PDF - Supplemental Material Download (282kB) | Preview

Abstract

PURPOSE: Employee performance evaluation is a common exercise conducted in many organizations. Employees need to know the feedback on their performance from the management. Often the results of performance evaluation exercises are used for promotion, confirmation in service and awarding of bonuses for employees. However, the performance evaluation exercise often meets with criticisms due to the presence of subjective factors and, specifically, how these factors are handled. The purpose of the present paper is to show how the Ratings mode of the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) can be applied to evaluate employee performance using objective as well as subjective criteria. METHODOLOGY: The whole AHP exercise for the present employee performance evaluation has been shown through a case study on CLSB, a company in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Four senior managers and the Managing Director of the company were involved in all the phases of the present evaluation exercise, including elicitation of the criteria, sub-criteria and assigning weights to them. The AHP data were analyzed using a software called AHP Calc version 24.12.13 developed by Klaus D. Goepel and available online. In particular, the Ratings mode of AHP was used to evaluate employees’ performance at CLSB. FINDINGS: Five criteria, namely Services, Quality, Financial, Timing, and Teamwork, are found to be important for the evaluation of employee performance at CLSB. Each of these criteria have sub-criteria. Harmonious work, Skills, and Punctuality are found to be the three most important sub-criteria for the present evaluation exercise. The outcome of the evaluation exercise provides an ordered set of ranks of 20 employees working in the company. Apart from the application of AHP for performance evaluation, an ordered set of detailed rubrics for all the criteria have been developed. The rubrics provide precise guidelines to the evaluators at the time of evaluating employees’ performance. IMPLICATIONS: An evaluation scheme that is scientific and systematic such as the present one, will minimize criticisms levied against performance evaluation exercise. Once the employees are aware of the criteria and sub-criteria set with the associated weighting scheme and the evaluation process itself, they will be motivated to perform their tasks and discharge their duties accordingly. Hence employee job satisfaction and their productivity are expected to increase. This will bolster not only the employees’ morale but also the organization’s overall performance. ORIGINALITY AND VALUE: In the literature, many schemes are available to evaluate employees' performance. But often, these methods are criticized as they either take all the criteria of evaluation as equally important or they lack the capability to strike a balance between objective and subjective factors. The main contribution of the present work is to show how AHP can alleviate the above drawbacks of the existing methods. The present research work has developed a performance evaluation method which is simple and straightforward, and the detailed steps have been elaborated on how the method can actually be applied to measure the performance of employees. The method can be applied to measure employees' performance of other companies with the necessary modification of the criteria set and assigning appropriate weights to them.

Item Type:	Article (Journal)
Uncontrolled Keywords:	Employee performance, Employee performance evaluation, Reward, Training need, AHP Ratings
Subjects:	H Social Sciences > HF Commerce > HF5001 Business. Business Administration > HF5549 Personnel management
Kulliyyahs/Centres/Divisions/Institutes (Can select more than one option. Press CONTROL button):	Kulliyyah of Economics and Management Sciences Kulliyyah of Economics and Management Sciences > Department of Business Administration
Depositing User:	Rafikul Islam
Date Deposited:	20 Jun 2023 09:21
Last Modified:	17 May 2024 16:05
URI:	http://irep.iium.edu.my/id/eprint/105193

Actions (login required)

View Item