IIUM Repository

Restitution of tax which has been paid under mistake of law

Jalil, Md. Abdul (2010) Restitution of tax which has been paid under mistake of law. Jurnal Undang-undang, 14. pp. 223-248. ISSN 1394-7229

[img] PDF (Restitution of tax which has been paid under mistake of law ) - Published Version
Restricted to Repository staff only

Download (2MB) | Request a copy


The court in the UK in 1802 applied the legal maxim ignorantia juris non excusat (which means ‘ignorance of law is no excuse’) in Bilbie v Lumley case which was involved in recovery of indemnity mistakenly paid by an insurance company to the insured. In this case the court held that insurance indemnity paid to the insured under mistake of law is not refundable because of the above maxim. In later cases courts in England also applied the above legal maxim in tax cases barring taxpayers from recovering tax paid under mistake of law. So, the above legal maxim became the English common law rule in almost every later case involving payment made under mistake of law. It is to be noted that the above legal maxim was originally developed to be applied in criminal cases. It seems that the above maxim of law was misapplied by the court in the Bilbie case in indemnity refund claim and other courts also misapplied the maxim in tax restitution cases. That maxim is acceptable in criminal cases but it is not applicable or desirable in recovery of money or tax paid under mistake of law. Hence, the House of Lords after almost two hundred years has overruled the Bilbie decision in Kleinwort Benson Ltd v Lincoln City Council, decided in 1998.

Item Type: Article (Journal)
Additional Information: 5963/13391
Uncontrolled Keywords: ignorita juris non excusat, insurance indemnity, mistake of law, tax restitution
Subjects: H Social Sciences > HJ Public Finance > HJ2240 Revenue. Taxation
K Law > K Law (General)
Kulliyyahs/Centres/Divisions/Institutes (Can select more than one option. Press CONTROL button): Kulliyyah of Economics and Management Sciences > Department of Business Administration
Depositing User: Dr Md Abdul Jalil
Date Deposited: 10 Jan 2012 17:37
Last Modified: 22 Feb 2012 09:22
URI: http://irep.iium.edu.my/id/eprint/13391

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year